Mahindra or Tata Cars - Which is Better?

When it comes to choosing a car in India, two popular names come to mind: Mahindra and Tata. Due to their individual strengths and weaknesses, we will assess a range of elements including safety, customer service experience, leadership, cost, performance, electric vehicles (EVs), popular models and customer reviews to help you determine the brand that could be best for you.

Safety

Mahindra

ABS (Anti-lock Braking System) and EBD (Electronic Brakeforce Distribution) alongside multiple airbags are notable features across many Mahindra models. As an example, the Mahindra XUV700 achieved a 5-star result in Global NCAP crash tests, which highlights its great safety features.

Tata

Tata is mainly distinguished for its safety innovations. The solid construction and handy safety features of the Tata Nexon and Tata Altroz have resulted in their earning 5-star ratings in Global NCAP. The focus of the brand is on a robust body architecture and added security options such as electronic stability control.

Service Experience

Mahindra

In general, Mahindra has better reviews concerning its service experience. Several customers have stated that they experienced a more responsive and friendly service team, together with good access to spare parts. The brand's attention to customer satisfaction is quite clear, thus it tends to be the preferred choice for a lot of individuals.

Tata

The service offered by Tata generates a variety of customer feedback. Some people value efficiency, in contrast, others indicate problems with delays and uneven service quality. The company is still focused on developing its after-sales service, but it has plenty of room to improve.

Leadership

Mahindra

Thanks to a long history in the automobile sector, Mahindra is currently led by a solid vision for both sustainability and growth under Anand Mahindra. The company performs exceptionally in the SUV market and has shown advancements in both ICE and electric segments.

Tata

Tata Motors is well recognised for its innovation and sustainability. With attention to electric vehicles and a focus on a cleaner future, the leadership shown by Tata takes a modern view of car manufacturing.

Cost of Cars

Mahindra

You can often find great value for your investment in Mahindra cars. About INR 7 lakhs is the starting point for vehicles including the Mahindra XUV3XO, escalating to INR 30 lakhs for premium versions such as the XUV700.

Tata

Tata’s pricing strategy is competitive as well. Models like the Tata Tiago start at Rs 5 lakh, while the premium Tata Safari can go up to Rs 15.49 lakh. Both brands offer a variety of options in different price segments, catering to a broad audience.

Performance

Mahindra

Mahindra SUVs are known for their ruggedness and off-road capabilities. Models like the Thar offer impressive performance in challenging terrains, equipped with powerful engines that provide good torque and handling. Out of the two, only Mahindra cars come with a 4x4 setup.

Tata

Their vehicles are often praised for their driving comfort and performance. The Tata Nexon’s 1.2-litre turbocharged petrol engine provides a lively drive, while the 1.5-litre diesel variant is known for its fuel efficiency and performance balance.

Electric Vehicles (EVs)

Mahindra

Mahindra is widening its EV catalogue by introducing vehicles such as the XUV400. Though the options are fewer than Tata's, the company is slowly increasing its EV strategy in anticipation of the launch of the Born Electric XUV.e8.

Tata

Right now, Tata is the market leader in India's EV segment, offering models like the Tata Nexon EV and the Tata Punch EV. Thanks to its practical range alongside its performance, the Nexon EV has become a well-liked product for those aiming to reduce their carbon footprint. The car was recently updated with a bigger 45kWh battery pack that returns a mileage of 489 kilometres. 

Customer Reviews

Mahindra

Customers consistently emphasise in their feedback about Mahindra cars the capability and long life of the vehicles. Yet, a portion of the users are talking about their worries about the service network as well as the availability of parts.

Tata

Tata receives favourable reviews for its stylish designs, safety features and overall value for money. Many customers appreciate the brand's efforts in the quality of their vehicles.

Verdict

Your wants and needs will affect your comparison of Mahindra and Tata. If you prioritise rugged performance along with a strong SUV selection, you should look into Mahindra as your choice. Should safety along with a long list of features and an impressive electric vehicle lineup carry more weight, Tata could very well be the superior choice. The ‘Made-in-India’ brands both have their advantages, so spend the time to investigate and test what works best for your needs.

Also read - Kia Seltos - Which Engine & Gearbox Combination to Buy?